Should Shane have lived longer or the Governor?
Both of them had they're mental issues, but the one with the most sanity is Shane, so I'd choose Shane, but they're both great characters.
You are right they were both sick that's a hard decision but I would choose Shayne because he would protect the group at all costs even though at times he made the choice. Even though his delivery was not on point he got the job done. If he didn't open the barn at Hershel's farm he would have never found Sophia. The only thing is Rick would definitely have to sleep with one eye open.
Yeah there were times when Shane was a saviour, but he's definitely insane.
I think Shane wasn't crazy or anything. I think he just understood this world way before anyone else did. Rick has gone WAY beyond the point that Shane ever did.
What do you think?