This article is about the TV Series character. You may be looking for his Comic Series or Road to Survival counterparts or the Novel character.
"Oh, honey, I'm not alone. I have Tammy and my son... Alden will take good care of Adam. And you, Judith, you're so strong. So brave. But now I need you to keep those kids safe from me. Please. Go back out there, and don't come near me again, okay?"
—Earl to Judith before his suicide.[src]

Earl Sutton is a survivor of the outbreak in AMC's The Walking Dead. He was a resident and the blacksmith of the Hilltop Colony, alongside his wife Tammy Rose and son Kenneth. Six years later, Earl and Tammy adopt an orphaned Whisperer baby and named him Adam Sutton. Sometime after the fair massacre and due to the lack of leadership, Earl becomes a member of the Hilltop Council.

Pre-Apocalypse

Khe Sanh, Vietnam

Earl served in the Vietnam War and was stationed outside of Khe Sanh during his second tour. While patrolling the hills around the village, Earl and a friend of his discovered a cache of Soviet-made SKS carbines. Earl reported these findings to his squad leader and agitated for him to take action, but was threatened for insubordination instead. Two days later, Earl's garrison was attacked as part of the Tet Offensive and suffered 155 deaths.[2]

Location Unknown

At some point, Earl married Tammy and had a son with her, Ken. He was an alcoholic, to the point that he was drunk when Ken was born and can't even remember the first time he saw him. When Ken was two, Earl got into a fight with the babysitter and drove off with Ken, drunk. He latter pulled over and called Tammy to pick them up. He expected his wife to leave him, but she didn't. From that day, Earl swore off drinking, staying sober for the next twenty years.

Post-Apocalypse

Virginia

At some point in the apocalypse, Earl and his family joined a community called the Hilltop Colony. Over time, he became the main blacksmith and he also helped in building jail cells in the Barrington house basement.

Season 9

When the community had democratic elections between Maggie and Gregory to elect a new leader, Earl was one of the residents who, despite not being convinced by Maggie's decisions to provide provisions to the Saviors, voted for her after taking into account Gregory's ineptitude to be a leader.

"A New Beginning"

Upon being informed by Maggie of Kenneth's death, Earl remains in silent as an emotional Tammy scolds Maggie for getting her son killed, reminding her that she voted for her in the election. Earl tries to calm her down but Tammy doesn't listen and criticizes Maggie's decision to supply the Saviors. He then chooses to leave the room. During Kenneth's funeral, a heartbroken Earl listens as Alden sings and then as Gregory gives a eulogy. He then helps to place the lid on the coffin and prepare to bury his son.

Gregory then approaches Tammy and Earl with a bottle of whiskey. She drinks herself to sleep, leaving Earl and Gregory to talk, with Gregory breaking Earl's non-drinking policy and taking advantage of him. Through some cunning words, Gregory suggests to Earl that Maggie does not have to be in charge of Hilltop anymore. When Maggie rushes towards Glenn's grave, she is attacked by a hooded and drunk Earl, who also knocks over Hershel's stroller. Enid intervenes but gets pushed to the ground hard and is knocked out. Alden and Cyndie arrive and manage to stop Earl.

The next night, a restrained Earl watches from the crowd as Maggie gives a speech to the residents about the punishment in the community and then orders for Gregory to be executed by hanging to the shock of everyone.

"The Bridge"

Following Gregory's execution, Earl is imprisoned in Hilltop's cell as punishment for over a month. When Maggie allows Tammy to see her husband, she tells him she forgives him and claims that what he did was a mistake and he's a good and changed man. They talk a little about their past and Earl says he needs the forgiveness of Maggie.

Later that day, Maggie talks to Earl herself. He mentions how he became an alcoholic, not remembering seeing his son for the first time and how an accident made him stop drinking for over twenty years. He says that despite being drunk he was aware of his actions and says he regrets trying to kill her. Eventually, Maggie releases him from his cell to pay his debt, since he made her remember how her father was an alcoholic too and got a second chance in life.

"Evolution"

Six years after Rick's assumed death, Earl now acts as a full-time blacksmith and has taken Alden as his apprentice. When Michonne and Siddiq arrive at Hilltop with a group of newcomers, he looks on as they talk with Tara and Enid. Later that day, Earl is at his blacksmith tent and offers his new apprentice Henry an invitation to have dinner with him and Tammy that night but Henry politely rejects him after seeing Alden and Enid kissing.

That night, Tara takes Earl down to the jail where Henry sits in a cell as punishment for misbehavior. Feeling disappointed and betrayed, Earl tells him he will no longer teach him and to return to the Kingdom. However, Henry explains his community is counting on him and begs for another chance. Earl then remembers that he once got spared too after his wrongful actions and promises to talk to Jesus when he returns.

"Bounty"

Earl is checked up by Enid for an injury and she suggests he retire, but he refuses. Tammy thanks Enid for helping and assures her Alden will turn up. When Alpha arrives outside the gates with a group of Whisperers to offer trading Alden and Luke for her captive daughter, Earl helps to look around the community for the missing Lydia

When Connie runs out of the cornfield, sling-shots a walker, and saves a baby left by the Whisperers to be devoured by an approaching herd, Earl, Tammy, Daryl, and Kelly step in to rescue her. At night, Earl and Tammy hold the baby and share a happy moment together, having decided to adopt the abandoned child.

"Chokepoint"

Earl is part of Tara's group in charge of clearing a tree from their path to the Kingdom to ensure the roads are cleared for Alden's convoy carrying the food and trade goods for the fair. While on the road, Earl tells Tammy not to get too attached to the baby as he deserves to be adopted by a younger couple.

Later that day, a small herd of walkers approaches the group. They get in position and remind themselves to watch for the Whisperers. Earl is almost bitten by a walker but is saved in time by Tammy. Suddenly, the Highwaymen ride up on horses and introduce themselves to Tara after helping to take down the herd. They then escort them to the Kingdom, having accepted Carol's deal.

Upon arriving at the Kingdom, Earl and Tammy are greeted by Nabila. She asks them about the baby and Tammy admits to Earl she wants to keep the baby with them. Earl smiles and embraces her.

"The Calm Before"

When the fair begins, Earl trades some of his blacksmithing work with some residents as Tammy carries her adopted son. They then walk around with their baby and talk about his new name. When Tammy suggests they should call him Adam, Earl jokingly mentions he had a friend in high school named Adam who was an asshole. Later that day, Earl looks around the fair for a missing Tammy with the help of Connie and Kelly.

The next day, Earl listens from the crowd as Siddiq delivers the tragic news about the fate of the missing fair attendees, tells them how brave the victims were in their final moments and how he was intentionally kept alive to tell this very story. He encourages everyone to remember the fallen as brave heroes and to honor them.

Season 10

"Lines We Cross"

Some months after the blizzard, Earl is among the coalition members drafted into the militia that was formed in response to the Whisperer threat. He and the other militia conduct a training exercise on the Oceanside beach. As Ezekiel and Jerry methodically release walkers from a shipwrecked boat, Earl and the other militia work together as a unit to take out the walker threat.

They are successful and return to Oceanside to rest, eat, and socialize with the Oceansiders. That night, Earl helps put out the fire that was ignited in the woods in Whisperer territory after a satellite from outer space crashes.

"Silence the Whisperers"

Earl is alerted to the commotion of a tree falling onto a house and a portion of Hilltop's walls. When the group debates if the Whisperers are responsible, Earl yells that they are already at war. He then helps the other residents rescue the trapped injured from the rubble.

The next day, Earl and the other residents kill the incoming walkers with the help of the Alexandria convoy when the herd invades the community that night. The following morning, Earl helps load the supplies onto the cart for the parting group towards Oceanside and watches as they leave the community.

"What It Always Is"

Earl helps out around the community following their recent attack and complains to Yumiko about their lack of retaliation against the Whisperers. Later that day, Earl tells Alden the Whisperers will eventually return while he claims he hasn't forgotten about what they had lost.

"Morning Star"

Alden and Earl are constructing defenses on the Hilltop's walls, when they spot a group of Alexandrians approaching, although neither recognize Mary. When Earl asks Aaron about this, the latter reveals Mary to be a former Whisperer that has defected, and that she wishes to see her nephew, Adam. Earl promptly shoots down this notion, not trusting Mary. Alden agrees with Earl, and assures him that they will only allow the Alexandrians to see Alex.

Yumiko instructs Felix and Penny to radio them as soon as they see the Whisperers approaching. She then joins the discussion about what should be done. Lydia thinks they should run, explaining that even if the explosion at the cave took out half the horde, Alpha would still have thousands of walkers left. Earl thinks the Whisperers might bypass them and go for Alexandria first, but Lydia negates this. Jerry wishes to stay and fight instead, while Dianne agrees with Lydia, believing that they can rebuild in another location. Earl is skeptical, however, and reckons that they will never find a place as good as Hilltop. While Yumiko points out they're heavily outnumbered, Earl insists that fighting is the best course of action, and even if they die, they will die for a place that means something. Aaron points out that there are children at Hilltop, too. Daryl agrees that they should get the kids out first, and instructs the others to pack up and regroup at Oceanside.

As everyone is gathered on the front lines including Earl. Kelly puts her palms on the ground and confirms that the horde is close. Indeed, the horde soon emerges from the bushes and approaches the Hilltop. While they are momentarily halted by the electric fence, the walkers soon break through it and approach the second line of defense. Aaron orders the survivors to split ranks. The shield-wielding survivors reinforce the makeshift barbed wire fence, while the melee weapon-wielding survivors start taking out the walkers. The archers, meanwhile, stay in the back and rain arrows on the herd. Behind the herd, Beta commands the Whisperers to launch the sap they collected earlier using makeshift catapults into the front lines, drenching most of the defenders as well as the Hilltop's walls. This is followed by the Whisperers launching fire-arrows into the front lines, setting one unfortunate Hilltop resident ablaze. With no choice, the defenders begin to retreat towards the Hilltop, but are trapped when the Whisperers launch another volley of fire-arrows into the Hilltop's walls, setting the community ablaze.

"Walk With Us"

Earl continues to participate in the battle to defend Hilltop. As the community falls, Earl finds Judith who has just killed a Whisperer and leads her and the other children to safety.

The next day, Earl and the children hole up in an abandoned shed where Earl comforts the kids and promises that their parents will be there soon. Entering the next room, Earl drives a railroad spike through a table, having been bitten in the arm. Judith enters and realizes what happened with Earl explaining that he intends to kill himself before he can turn so that he won't be a threat to the children. Earl refuses Judith's offer to be at his side, stating that he won't be alone as he can now be with Tammy Rose and Ken while Alden will take care of Adam. After Judith leaves the room, Earl braces himself and then slams his head against the spike.

Shortly afterwards, Judith enters the room to find Earl dead, but that he had failed at impaling himself on the spike. With his brain still intact, Earl reanimates and Judith quickly puts him down with her katana. Arriving moments later with Ezekiel and Jerry, Daryl finds Judith crying beside Earl's corpse and comforts her.

Death

Killed By

During the attack on Hilltop caused by the Whisperers, Earl was bitten by a walker.

  • Himself (Alive, Suicide)

In order to prevent himself from turning, Earl tried to impale his head on a railroad spike. However, Earl only succeeds in splitting his head open and fails to destroy his brain.

After Earl reanimates, Judith stabs him in the head with her katana.

Killed Victims

This list shows the victims Earl Sutton has killed:

  • Gregory (Indirectly Caused)
  • Himself (Alive, Suicide)
  • Possibly numerous enemy combatants (Pre-Apocalypse)
  • Possibly a few unnamed Whisperers (Alongside Alden)
  • Numerous counts of zombies

Relationships

Tammy Rose Sutton

Earl and Tammy Rose are shown to have a loving, committed marriage. Tammy stood by Earl through his addiction and never gave up on him, which Earl is shown to be grateful for. Earl is also shown to have regret emotionally hurting Tammy and their son during his addiction pre-apocalypse. When he finds out about his wife's death at the hands of Alpha, he is deeply saddened.

Kenneth Sutton

Though they aren't shown interacting on screen, it can be inferred that Earl and Kenneth had a loving, father-son relationship. Earl is shown to be devastated by his son's sudden death.

Maggie Rhee

Earl and Maggie initially had a stable relationship, as it is mentioned that Earl and Tammy voted for Maggie in the Hilltop Election. Their relationship takes a turn for the worse following the death of Earl's son, Kenneth. Earl and Tammy blame Maggie for their son's death. A drunken Earl is persuaded by Gregory to attack and try to kill Maggie, but ultimately fails and is thrown into the Hilltop Jail by Maggie and kept for over a month. Maggie decides to forgive and release Earl from prison after a heartfelt conversation between the two, and Maggie is reminded of her father and the fact that if he had not been given a second chance that a lot of people wouldn't still be alive. Their relationship is shown to improve following these events.

Gregory

Earl and Gregory are shown to have a negative relationship. Following the death of his son, Kenneth, Earl is manipulated into attempting to kill Maggie by Gregory, who gets Earl drunk. Earl is shown to spite Gregory for this and have great regret for his actions.

Alden

Earl and Alden have a positive working relationship, as Earl has taken Alden on as his apprentice. In "Bounty", it's mentioned that Earl and his wife Tammy Rose have become like parents to Alden and Enid. As a result, Earl takes Alden's disappearance hard.

Henry

Earl is shown to like and respect Henry as he takes Henry on as an apprentice blacksmith and even invites him to dinner with he and Tammy Rose on his first day of apprenticeship. He is shown to be disappointed when Henry stands him up to sneak out with his new friends and ends up in jail from drunken disorder, but Earl forgives Henry as he is reminded of when Maggie forgave him 6 years prior. Earl tells Henry that he will attempt to bail him out. He apparently succeeds in getting Henry only sentenced to the two nights in jail required for a drunk and disorderly and not kicked out of the Hilltop as Daryl later tells Henry that Earl said Henry can't be set free until he finishes his two night sentence.

Judith Grimes

Earl cared about Judith's safety. When Hilltop was attacked, Earl took her and the rest of the children to safety. When Earl was bitten, Judith wanted to be with him so he wouldn't be alone. Earl refused and asked her to go back with the other kids to protect them from him, and then attempts to kill himself so he wouldn't turn. Afterwards, Judith comes back into the room to check on him, only to find him dead but having failed to destroy his brain. Earl suddenly turns and grabs Judith, but she quickly puts him down with her katana. After putting him down, Judith cries in the corner, showing she cared about him.

Mary

Along with Alden, Earl has a belligerent and aggressive distrust of Mary due to her past affiliation with the Whisperers, and is unwilling to let her see his adopted son Adam, who is Mary's biological nephew.


Appearances

TV Series

Season 9

Season 10

Trivia

  • It is hinted in "Bounty" that Earl may have suffered from arthritis.
  • Earl is the last known member of his family to die.

References

TV Series Characters
Grimes Family JudithR.J.RickCarlLori
King County LambertPaulaShaneLeonMr. SiggardMrs. Siggard
Jones Family MorganJennyDuane
Atlanta Camp CarolDarylMoralesGlennAndreaMerleTheodoreDaleSophiaJacquiMirandaLouisElizaAmyEdJim
Nursing Home MiguelFelipeJorgeGuillermoGilbert
Jenner Family EdwinCandace
Greene Farm MaggieBethHershelPatriciaJimmyAnnetteShawnArnoldOtisJosephine
Military Personnel WellesWilsonBradySeanFranklinCallaway
The Living NateRandallSeanTonyDave
Michonne's Group MichonneMikeTerryAndre
The Prison AxelOscarAndrewTomasBig Tiny
Woodbury JeanetteMrs. RichardsMs. McLeodPhilipCaesarShumpertMr. JacobsonKarenMr. RichardsOwenErynGregMiltonDr. StevensRowanEileenFosterBettyNoahPaulJodyRichardHaleyPennyWarrenMichaelGargulioCrowleyTimEmily
Tyreese's Group SashaTyreeseAllenBenDonna
Prison Newcomers BobLizzieMikaLukeMollyJulioHenryNorisCalebDavidRyanCharlieChloePatrickZach
Chambler Family TaraLillyMeghanDavid
Martinez's Group HowardMitchAlishaPete
Ford Family AbrahamEllenA.J.Becca
Post-Prison Survivors EugeneRositaChristopher
The Claimers DanBillyHarleyTonyJoeLenLou
Terminus MartinGregTheresaGarethAlbertMikeMaryAlex
St. Sarah's Church Gabriel
Grady Memorial Hospital StevenTanakaAlvaradoAmandaBelloLicariPercyMcGinleyFrancoNoahDawnO'DonnellBobJeffriesGormanJoanGavinHanson
Alexandria Safe-Zone AaronScottKyleSocorroBarbaraHeathNoraMrs. RobinsonAlexJenWayneCherylEnidRussBobBruceTobinKent AnnaMikeyFrancineSpencerOliviaDeniseDeannaLucyRonJessieSamMayaDavidBetsyNicholasAnnieWillTommySturgessBarnesNatalieStacyMichaelJefferyRichardsHollySamanthaBobbyCharlyneO'HaraDineshDanErinAdrianParkShellyCarterPeteRegAidenEric
The Wolves OwenAphid
The Saviors NeganAldenGracieSherryDwightAmberTanyaMarkGinaQuanPotterJoséBrookeMelJohnMarcusJonahAliceLauraBrandonFrankieD.J.RichieRegina JedNorrisArat JustinSimonDukeLanceGaryReillyJaredEvanKatyKenoDerekDeanGavinGomezPaulieDukeZiaLeoYagoJoeyGuntherRudyToddDinoHuckWadeCamNelsonMaraGordonRoyDavidEmmettIsabelleJosephChrisGeorgeNeilRomanJiroMilesPrimoPaulaMichelleMollyDonnieGabeTimmyTina
Hilltop Colony BertieOscarMarcoHershelKalEduardoGageBriannaEarlPennyFelixAdelineRodneyTammy RoseCasperMartinMilesHildePaulGregoryKennethStephanieCraigCrystalWesleyHarlanNeilFreddieAndyEthan
The Kingdom EzekielJerryDianneNabilaEzraAliyahMariamJennyWilliamHenryDanaKevinKurtAlvaroDanielColtonRichardBenjamin
Oceanside CyndieRachelBeatriceJulesKathyNatania
The Scavengers AnneTamielBrionFarronWinslow
Georgie's Group HildaMidgeGeorgie
Magna's Group MagnaLukeKellyYumikoConnieBernie
The Whisperers LydiaAdamBetaAlphaRufusMaryDanteFrancesZionRasmusSeanHelen
Shelter Survivors CyrusAmandaLamarFrankRoseMatias
The Highwaymen AlfredMargoAlekOzzy
Jocelyn's Group WinnieP.J.GinaLinusMitchellJocelyn
Bloodsworth Island VirgilLucyCelesteJeremiahLisa
Survivor Caravan AidenBailey
Miscellaneous Survivors JuanitaWilhelmSiddiqMiloAmeliaEastmanSamAnaMrs. BlakeClara
Animals DogNellyShivaTabithaButtonsDukeFlameViolet
Walkers CarlaDellyJoe Sr.BillTonyNickErinDougLouiseWayneSummerHannahEddie
Alive characters appear in green. Dead characters appear in red and italics. Unknown characters appear in blue. Undead characters appear in gray and italics.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.