The issue opens up with Negan threatening someone, but it is revealed that he's just talking to flowers, which he takes to his wife's grave. He apologizes to her and expresses his loneliness and fear of dying.
Negan enters his house and discovers a stranger inside. She apologizes for breaking in and asks him to spare some food, which he agrees to. The stranger introduces herself as Lucy, which surprises Negan due to the similarity of her name and his wife Lucille's.
Negan and Lucy share a meal and discuss how the apocalypse forces them to constantly adjust to new situations. Lucy moves closer to Negan and asks if he lives alone, which he confirms is true. She questions him about nearby communities; he tells her there are some places close by, but he doesn't trade with them because they dislike him. Lucy compliments his appearance, causing Negan to jump up. He asks where the rest of her group is, refusing to believe she's on her own. He suspiciously comments that she looks too well-kept to be a lone survivor in the wilderness, and that a woman half his age wouldn't fall for him so easily. Lucy tells him he's smarter than he looks.
Derick and Barry jump out of the woods, the latter strangling Negan with a rope. Lucy pleads for his life but Derick urges Barry to finish the job. Negan insults them, saying they're too weak to kill him even though he's not fighting back. Derick gives Negan a shovel and makes him dig up Lucille's grave, which they plan to bury Negan in. He begs them not to force him to continue, but he ends up complying after Derick threatens to kill Lucy. Derick asks him who's buried in the grave, saying they must be special if he'd rather die than dig them up. Negan tells him that it's his baseball bat, which is representative of his deceased wife. Derick says his story is the "stupidest shit [he's] ever heard".
Walkers attack, killing Barry. Derick shoots some of them, but gets bitten. Negan uses the shovel to kill the walker biting him, as he wants to kill Derick himself. He stabs and kills him in the chest with the shovel, attempting to cut him in half. A scared Lucy asks if Negan plans to kill her, but he instead invites her to join him on his newfound quest to lay his wife's bones to rest, telling her, "Don't you want to see what happens next?".
- First (and last) appearance of Lucy. (Unknown)
- First (and last) appearance of Derick.
- First (and last) appearance of Barry.
- This will be the second comic to feature Negan as the protagonist, the first being Here's Negan.
- This is also the first time that a second comic issue has been made for a character.
- The ending of this issue hints at the possibility that there may be a follow up to this story but that has yet to be confirmed.
- Robert Kirkman says in the letter hacks "I can honestly say I don't know if we'll ever actually see 'what happens next'. To me, you see the headstone in #193, the story is pretty much told... but I'll never say never. But probably never. Probably..."
- The letter hacks confirm that Clementine is alive.
- Kirkman states at the end "P.S. Clementine Lives", this is very similar to how Issue 193 ended with "P.S. Negan Lives".
- The letter hacks confirm part of reason as to why this issue was made was that in Issue 193, we see Negan visiting a tombstone for Lucille, however, in Issue 174 the grave is just marked with a simple wooden cross ergo a backstory was needed for this.
- The letter hacks confirm that Charlie Adlard was against killing Negan in Issue 174.
|The Walking Dead Specials|
|The Governor Special|
|Negan Special 2|