• Expound your thoughts and opinions about this guy who shot numerous women with his Mossberg, Shane Walsh.

    ShaneS2CastPic
      Loading editor
    • I loved Shane he was definitely one of my favourite charecters and I thought his charecter was much better then the comic count her part.

        Loading editor
    • One of the most developed characters of TV Series, and one of the few characters better than their comic book counterpart. I can't say he was my favorite character at all, but he was a really good character and antagonist to the TV Series.

        Loading editor
    • What they did with shane is some of their best content. Season 2 was worth it for all the shane content

        Loading editor
    • Well developed, but I hate him.

        Loading editor
    • ^I agree with 123.

      He was a well developed character, but I hated his guts for being so slimey to Rick.

      However, from a writing standpoint, a character that makes the viewer feel like that is a great character.

        Loading editor
    • He deserved to die tbh. He was really rude towards everyone and practically put them in danger. 

        Loading editor
    • Shane was awesome character,but that bitch Lori stood between him and Rick...ey

      "Rick could you please kill Shane?"

      "Sure honey!

      3 episodes later

      "I killed Shane"

      "YOU MONSTER!"

        Loading editor
    • Mrluka1998 wrote:
      Shane was awesome character,but that bitch Lori stood between him and Rick...ey

      "Rick could you please kill Shane?"

      "Sure honey!

      3 episodes later

      "I killed Shane"

      "YOU MONSTER!"

      Lol, so true. Lori is what ruined Shane. Glad she is dead now. She is way too dramatic, and very bitchy.

        Loading editor
    • I think it safe to say Jon made Shane and not the other way around.

        Loading editor
    • I miss him. He was a well developed character. He could've been a good guy if Lori wasn't there driving him insane. I'm sure he would've been useful throughout season 3. He'd have the Governor already dead.

        Loading editor
    • He was so much better in the show.

        Loading editor
    • Shane was a great character in the TV show. 'Nuff Said.

        Loading editor
    • Imagine how interesting season 3 would have been with Shane. Lori would have given birth and things would have got 1000% times worse than on the farm. Not to mention it would be a battle for power between him and Rick, which I thought would have been great to see. 

        Loading editor
    • TheWalkingGinge wrote:
      Imagine how interesting season 3 would have been with Shane. Lori would have given birth and things would have got 1000% times worse than on the farm. Not to mention it would be a battle for power between him and Rick, which I thought would have been great to see. 

      Imagine the Terminus situation now if he was still alive, H.A.M...

      and head-
      Headrub
      rubbing greatness too
        Loading editor
    • TheWalkingGinge wrote:
      Imagine how interesting season 3 would have been with Shane. Lori would have given birth and things would have got 1000% times worse than on the farm. Not to mention it would be a battle for power between him and Rick, which I thought would have been great to see. 

      True, but i think it would rob the development of other characters. OR, it would take longer for them to be developed. I.E. Daryl, Herschel, Glenn, The Governor, Merle, etc.

        Loading editor
    • Season 2 belonged to Shane, from his killing by zombie of Otis, slow descent into evil and ultimately his death and undeath, they were some of the standout moments of the entire show so far. You were willing him to step away from the edge and rejoin Rick and in the end you really felt Ricks pain when he was left with no choice. A shame he couldn't have continued in the show longer but you can understand why he was killed off and the resonance his death caused is what makes TWD such a great programme.

        Loading editor
    • I think that s3 would have played out COMPLETELY differently, had Shane been there. IMO Shane would have killed the prisoners on-sight, which may have stopped Lori's death. I think he would have agreed with Merle on outright killing the Governor and it would have meant the Governor wouldn't be around in s4 and they wouldn't have had to leave the prison, and presumably the illness outbreak wouldn't have happened. Idk

        Loading editor
    • He would've shot everybody, he probably would have shot michonne too which they'd never know about glenn and maggie, and maybe he would have killed tyreese and his group too. I don't know though.

        Loading editor
    • Daryl: Shane 2.0

        Loading editor
    • Oh My god. I LOVED Shane. The actor is great to! Shane started out great, until Rick came back. I honestly thought he had good intentions for the things he did. I know people who said they hated him for breaking open the barn door on the farm, right after saying those mean things to Carol. To that i say, if that never hapended, they would have wasted time looking for sophia.



      I say, he was a great Character, the way hey developed him, that was a fantastic character. If there was no Shane, the season 2 would have been a waist.


      A for season 2 goes, that was basicly a Shane season. But, yet it was still my favorite season. He made the whole show AMZING!




      Anyway, that is my look n the shane Character. He was defanity one of the best and most developed characters.\!


      Shaneattack
        Loading editor
    • XZoom wrote:
      He deserved to die tbh. He was really rude towards everyone and practically put them in danger. 

      Yeah, but think about how he helped them. He helped Glenn under the car, he opened the bar, which revealed where Sophia was. Ect.

        Loading editor
    • In the comics he didn't do anything.

        Loading editor
    • I would think Shane would be slightly more open to people joining the group, although he'd make it clear to them first that he has his eye on them. Shane and Merle could have worked out their differences (at Daryl's request) And quite frankly, his reappearance on the show, even in hallucination form, was the highlight of that episode. He'd give the governor a run for his money, and yeah, I think he'd snap Gareth's neck and burn terminus to the ground.

        Loading editor
    • Shane was my favourite character in the TV show. In the comics, he was still a favourite of mine, but he was killed off too soon to be as high on my list as TV Shane is.

        Loading editor
    • My opinion of Shane? I've read the comics, but only in the compendium books, and I thought comic Shane didn't contribute to much. TV Shane on the other hand was a great character. He was well developed, smart, funny at times, and he would made a great leader with Rick if Lori wasn't such a cunt to him. It was Lori's fault that Shane went crazy. It was her fault for causing Rick to kill him. I'm glad that we got to explore a bit more about Shane in the TV series, cause he was killed off way too early in the comics. I'd say Shane was probably my favorite antagonist in this show. Rest in peace Shane. 

        Loading editor
    • Shane's a great and complex character, one of my favorites. 

        Loading editor
    • he was a great character to hate...obviously he wasnt going to last long but we have better villans now with the gov and gareth

        Loading editor
    • Great in a fight. Willing to get the job done, maybe a bit too much so especially when you take into account him Otising Otis. His severe downfall was Lori. Shame he couldn't get past it.

        Loading editor
    • Lori: I think Shane killed Otis Later.... (Lori begins to hug Rick) Rick: I killed Shane (Lori gets scarred)

        Loading editor
    • He rubbed his head too much.

        Loading editor
    • It's not COMPOLETELY Lori's fault for shane becoming insane-Shane. His lust for her also would have been the reason. Shane was an awesome character before he went crazy. If he stayed alive in season 3, Rick could have been killed in the season 2 finale, Lori would have lived considering when Andrew ran, Shane would have killed him. Shane would have went with Merle in killing the Goveno- never mind, Shane would have killed Merle, resulting with Daryl leaving and then him dying since he'd be all on his own. Also, Carl would have become more badass and stuff

        Loading editor
    • Gregsson88 wrote:
      He rubbed his head too much.

      IKR

        Loading editor
    • i love how cute all these people are, saying how they hate shane or didnt like him. same applies for the governor. its as if they are holding these characters to the higher standards of real-life people while ignoring that obvious fact that as an audience, we were actually supposed to hate those certain actions that make these men less than "good" men. that was the whole point of their characters. to set up belieavable circumstances in which the character must do something awful to survive or to gain what they want or need. if you are one of these dummies who hates/dislikes certain characters on the show/comic because theyve done bad things or breached your set of values and morals, i dont know how to make you understand, but it means you actually do like them as characters. theyre making you think and take a hypothetical stand and making you feel uncomfortable, angry, or feel anything really. Thats what good writing is and what good characters look like. 

        Loading editor
    • BroTaku wrote:
      It's not COMPOLETELY Lori's fault for shane becoming insane-Shane. His lust for her also would have been the reason. Shane was an awesome character before he went crazy. If he stayed alive in season 3, Rick could have been killed in the season 2 finale, Lori would have lived considering when Andrew ran, Shane would have killed him. Shane would have went with Merle in killing the Goveno- never mind, Shane would have killed Merle, resulting with Daryl leaving and then him dying since he'd be all on his own. Also, Carl would have become more badass and stuff

      Rick respects carl as a young man though. he let him disobey all the time as if "boys will be boys". and its let him grow into one of the most formidable and capable members of his group. if shane were carl's father, carl would have learned to always do as hes told, spend all his time combat training and bodyguarding his own mother from walkers. i feel like that carl would be super boring and not compelling. considering that without rick's offer to help, daryl would have left the show, branched off his own scenes in episode 4 of season 1, i dont think shane would re-encounter merle before daryl nor that the governor would meet him maybe at all. the cautering tools he used to seal his arm stump was still supposedly wet and warm when daryl and co. found it and presumably, alone, daryl wouldnt have attracted the Vatos' attention and would have remained hotter on merles tail. oh and then the whole series might end at the conclusion of the same episode because without ricks sheriffs bag of weapons + rick and daryl as two additional capable marksmen + tdog and glenn as two poor marksmen but still being armed. shane had just been caught off guard by amys screams throwing carl and lori behind his back. unfortunately he only managed to pick up a shotgun in the commotion. presumably retaining only it and his sidearm 9mm. these weapons alone, dale firing his hunting rifle and the rest using melee, Shane probably would have implulsively ran to get them far away. 

        Loading editor
    • I liked Shane until after Otis died, then he just went insane afterwards. 

      Before though he cared about Rick, Carl and Lori. He just disagreed with Rick and his actions, he was the only one who spoke against him. Sure, Shane was dickhead but that was just his character.

      I think Shane was easily the most developed out of everyone in Season Two. I think the best moments in Two were the Shane moments.

      All in all, Shane was a good man, but circumstances and lust turned him the other way.

        Loading editor
    • Shane was a bit much most of the time but I always loved his complex relationship with Rick. It was a truly fascinating thing to watch good friends turn on each other like that. It's my favorite part to explore about this show. Most everyone on this show was probably very normal and decent before everything happened.

        Loading editor
    • Tv Shane is more written,no wonder CS Shane is less good,he is one of the characters I'll never forget what they did

        Loading editor
    • Shane Walsh, was killed by Rick and Carl ! and we might have a very big problem with that TV series and also, everyone needs to explain to me what happened to Shane? 

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.