Gareth should have remained alive at least till mid-season finale. I really don't understand promoting him to series regular only to kill him 3 episodes later. I know his comics counterpart lived for a very short time, but I think the Hunters/Terminus could easily be expanded. I think the biggest mistake was to follow comics too closely - there was no way out. And I still can't believe than only 6 Terminus residents made out alive while Rick's group (16 people) escaped unharmed..
I do think Gareth should lived longer. For his short story arc it was amazing from start to finish. But should of been longer. This is how I would did it.
No Santuary- Great leave how it is. Strangers- Instead of what they did which was great and loved the ending. I would have it be a background on Terminus and The Hunters. Have it show early Terminus a helpful place. But then have the strangers show up and turn them into evil cannibals. Four Walls and A Roof- Have it be how strangers originally is. Fear the Hunters- Hunters and Bobs death. This would be better in my opinion, have more background of Hunters and little longer
I agree with you except for the last statement. I think TWD already passed its low point and that was season 3, season 4 was a big improvement in my opinion and season 5 even better.
Seasons 3 and 4 were much better than season 5... Everythang happened so fast in season 5, also the fucking fillers with fucked up hospital, with bitch Beth and Dawn... It was totally pointless... They should´ve make it like Beth´s been eaten by Terminusers...
Do you really think Rick would trust Gareth?
Gareth is a child murdering cannible, that kidnapped the group. He tried to kill them, and eat them. If Rick trusted him after that, I would lose half my interest in the show.
It doesn't matter if you liked the character, his development had run out.
And from the characters prespective, keeping him alive was insane.
Plue he had a really annoying voice.
I'm sorry but that's rediculous.
The show is a lot different and very unpredictable. If you think they are too close together, just get out, becauuse you're talking absolute shit at the moment.
The point of killing Dale, Patricia, Lori and Axel "too soon" was to keep the show predictable. Make up your mind, for God's sake, and until you have, please don't post false information.
And how exactly did Lost go downhill? It got better and better by season.
Good Lord this person.
Gareth is a child murdering cannible, that kidnapped the group. He tried to kill them, and eat them. If Rick trusted him after that, I would lose half my interest in the show.
It doesn't matter if you liked the character, his development had run out.
And from the characters prespective, keeping him alive was insane.
Plue he had a really annoying voice.
I didn´t want Rick to trust him, but they were travelling to Terminus for a whole second half of S4 and ONE person destroyed it in ONE episode... They should´ve made better storyline with Terminus, I´d be happier if Gareth and Terminusers have stayed there for the whole first half of S5, with no Dawn and the annoying bitch Beth already dead...
Yeah, I think so too. His death was too early.
No, his comic counterpart lasted only 4 issues and Gareth lasted 4 episodes. So actually Gareth outlived his counterpart, considering at least 2 or 3 issues make up one episode.
As much as I liked the character and actor his stint was sufficient. I prefer having an amazing short plot versus something that's prolonged and drained. He came in with a bang and went out even louder.
4 Wall & a Roof is my fav episode because it is the only episode that has made me flinched.