• I'm sure many of you are sick and tired of me bringing up subjects similar to this, but I still need to ask. What exactly are the requirements for there to be for family members not associated by blood. For weeks I've been trying to debate on how Clementine and AJ should be put into each-other's family section and almost every discussion I've seen the idea was immediately rejected. I'm aware that there was a discussion in the past about not accepting these kinds of familial bonds, but that was only because of Clem's relationship with Lee and while I would've wanted that to be true, I have to speak out and say that has nothing to do with the family tie with Clem and AJ. Clem has been taking care of AJ ever since his biological mother gave birth to him. She's practically raised AJ for four of the five years he's been alive and yet they're still not considered a part of the family. I'm not going to bother whining about how pets or romantic partners are considered family since I know that's been decided a long time ago. But I want a real explanation as for why Clem and AJ can't be seen as family. Like I said before if it's about Lee, AJ has nothing to do with that long since finished debate. Furthermore I know two instances where adoptive family bonds were accepted. Carol and Michonne. If you remember, Carol agreed to look after two sisters after their father perished. Much like Clem, Carol was tasked with being their caretaker as well as their survival mentor and also like Clem, neither children addressed her as "mom" (Although I admit Lizzie called her mom once, but Carol told her not to). As for Michonne, I'm not talking about Judith, but rather Carl. While I'm not denying Michonne and Carl's relationship did have incredible value, I don't qualify Michonne dating his dad as any kind of adoption. I know she called Carl her son when she was talking to Negan, but that was more of a sentimental value like how Rick said Daryl was his brother. While I personally don't want to ruin these threads, I'm trying to point out that Clem and AJ's relationship as adoptive mother and son is no different than the adoptive families you have signed off on. The only other difference I can see besides the Lee argument is how Clem is, but I don't see that as a big issue.

    Please respond.

      Loading editor
    • Can we not please

        Loading editor
    • I'm sorry for troubling you, but I have questions and in some ways you still haven't given me answers. I'm not trying to bug you, but everytime I try you automatically shut me down. I get it. You've been asked this question so many times you don't feel like explaining in detail because you expect me to know, but that's the thing, I don't. I wouldn't be doing this if I did. If you can't fufill my request I want you to explain to me every point as for why it can't happen. That's the only way I'm going to give up.

        Loading editor
    • Kent Mudle himself stated on his Tumblr that Clem and AJ don't share a mother-son bond, nor a brother-sister one. Clem and AJ just really care about each other and that's about it. Carl also looked up to Michonne as a mother figure, it wasn't a one-sided thing where only Michonne felt like a family member; both of them did. Also, Carol only said to not call her mom because she already lost a child. She was still their adoptive mother, one line doesn't get rid of that.

        Loading editor
    • Took the words right outta my mouth

        Loading editor
    • First response: Can you send me the link where he said that please? Second response: I understand what you're saying, I was really poking out that their relationship was no more official than the other adoptive families Third response: I don't really disagree, I just wanted to express that the word "mom" was never used to back my support.

      Having said that thank you for at least explaining to me why that is.

        Loading editor
    • Couldn't find the one I mentioned specifically but I found another ask where he summarizes a few of his original points:

      The Tumblr ask.

        Loading editor
    • Thanks for showing me. I'll stop now, but there's one more question I have. How does Clementine feel about it. I know AJ doesn't fully understand the concept, but what is Clem's perspective on it? if you can't tell me, I understand.

        Loading editor
    • Nothing's been said on Clem's view as far as I know, sadly.

        Loading editor
    • Oh okay, but thank you very much. You've finally given my closure and I appreciate you breaking it down for me and as promised I will stop.

        Loading editor
    • No problem.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.