Lastcat3 wrote:
KeepOnKeepingOn wrote:
Lastcat3 wrote:
Narutorulez wrote:
Lastcat3 wrote:
Narutorulez wrote:
didn't Enid say she was Henry's age when her parents died ? i thought she was around Carl's age in season 5 and she lost her parents way before like 13 ? if she's 23- 7-8 years since Carl's death her age would b 15-16 so it ads up but she's still few years younger than Henry when her parents died. This confirms Enid was a spy for the wolves but was never outed because she enjoyed living to much.
The ages with the kid characters in this show have always been really screwy. I think it was officially said in the show during season 1 that Carl was 9. So he officially should have only been around 11 or 12 or so come season 7 and 8 but the actor was 17 or 18 by then. So as a result I think they just left things open to interpretation over how old the kids were in the show.
If they had known back then that the show would go on as long as it did they probably would have had Rick and Laurie have a teenage kid (similar to what they did in Fear) that way it could be played by a person in their early 20's who had already done 99% of their growing.
They are going to run into the same problem with Judith here in a couple years. The actress is currently 12 and will be 13 by the time this season ends yet she is playing a character who is only about 7 or 8. If she stays in the show until the very end she will be a highschool kid playing a 9 year old.
That might be why Judith hasn't been in the show very much so far this season because Cailey is starting to become too old for the role.
Carl was 12 in season one so e would've been 14-15. The actor could pass for 14-15. Chandler wasn't that old looking. College will age him though. College aged me like a mf. :( than again he's also rich so who knows
Judith is 9-10 she'll be fine.
No there is an official episode early on in the shows run that says he was 9 (it was during an argument that Rick and Laurie were having). I think this wiki just decided to change the age on their own accord in order to try to line things up better.
Can you stop throwing this wiki under the bus when you yourself never contribute to it outside of responding to forum threads
If you have such a gripe with us then try to change things
You can do things how you wish on here but it doesn't mean you shouldn't be criticized from time to time for how you do handle things. I get that some people on here don't mind playing loose with canon (as they consider wikis as being more of an interpretation than a 100% accurate source) but given that there are franchises that keep canon very tight you can see why some wouldn't think much of a wiki like this.
And as for this this is simply a forum to talk about the franchise. It's not like I am going into the articles of the wiki and leaving nasty comments or anything.
I’m fine with criticism, but this is a wiki free for everyone to edit. I feel like it might be unwarranted to make comments like that without putting in the effort to make changes.
At the very least, your critiques come off as very passive aggressive at times and to me that feels unwarranted.