I just personally find those 2 seasons to be just boring as fuck. I know people say season 4 and particularly 5 are boring but I strongly disagree. Season 2 and 3 imo are just bad. They don’t make Alicia, Madison, or Nick more memorable, they just make them more boring if anything. The way those seasons looked was unappealing to look at. Kim dickens I don’t feel did that good of a job in terms of portraying Madison. Troy I also found to be just forgettable as well. The music also is pretty forgettable. The make up on the walkers and the gore was okay and some of the locations were cool but that’s it. Those seasons are just extremely mediocre for me. Again this is my opinion, you don’t have to agree. But that’s just my personal thoughts.