There’s a bit of a debate going on as to whether or not Barbara and Scott belong on the list of Ricks’ group.
Personally I’d say Scott has earned his place, but even though Barbara took care of Judith during season 8 she isn’t really “there”. She’s mostly in the background, and doesn’t have many important scenes or lines.
My memory is fuzzy on past seasons, but I think Scott has had some moments in the spotlight? More than Barbara anyway.
MisterTrouble says why not, though I disagree, SpaceBeyonder and I feel it should be core members only, so maybe we should just let guys decide.